Best Bloody Mary Contest

September 7, 2019    10AM
Two Brothers Bar & Grill

Who makes the area’s Best Bloody Mary?

Chilimania’s fifth annual Best Bloody Mary Contest will be held at 10 a.m. on Saturday, Sept. 7, 2019 at Two Brothers Pub & Grill, 116 W. Fulton Street in downtown Edgerton.

Come and enjoy the best Bloody Marys the Edgerton area has to offer, and you could be chosen to help decide the winners! Admission is FREE … but you must be age 21+ to register to be a judge. Judges will be chosen that morning using a lottery system.

How does this work?

Our goal is to have a FUN time and find out which local bar can create the BEST-LOOKING and BEST-TASTING Bloody Mary!

The competitors’ Bloody Mary mix and booth presentation will be judged and awarded in two categories:

  • Best Taste: How pleasing it is to the eyes and taste buds. A blind tasting of mixtures excluding any dressings, condiments, and/or garnishes.
  • Best Booth: How good it looks aesthetically. Bring your decoration skills!

In 2018, we also began awarding a People’s Choice award, given to the establishment chosen by contest attendees.


The winning bar will receive a “traveling trophy” plaque with their bar’s name inscribed, which they can display throughout the year. Chilimania will also bring the party to the establishment that wins Best Overall Taste (at a later date) to formally crown the Best Bloody Mary of 2018!

Past Winners

Best Overall Taste

  • 2018: Two Brothers Bar & Grill
  • 2017: Last Nite Bar & Grill
  • 2016: Snuffy’s Still
  • 2015: Red Baron
  • 2014: Snuffy’s Still

Best Booth

  • 2018: Lake House
  • 2019: Lake House

Best Looking

  • 2019: Snuffy’s Still

People’s Choice

  • 2018: Snuffy’s Still
  • 2019: Lake House

Session Category :  Chilimania